Band 4.5 IELTS Writing Task 1 Model Answer

Overall Band Score: 4.5 · Cambridge IELTS 18 · 2026-11-21

IELTS Writing Task 1 question

The graph below gives information about the percentage of the population in four Asian countries living in cities from 1970 to 2020, with predictions for 2030 and 2040. Summarize the information by selecting and reporting the main features and make comparisons where relevant.

 

Student answer (Band 4.5)

The given graph compares between the population predictions in 4 Asian countries from 2030 to 2040. Comes in the first place Malaysia with the highest growth rate of 80% by 2040, followed by Indonesia with a noticeable difference of 20% where Malaysia reaches 60% by 2040, then thrid and fourth are Philippines then Indonesia. Malasysia has almost always been the country with the highest population of them all except in 1970 where Philippines has higher population and in 1990 where it preceedes Philippines but the difference wasn't big. On the other hand in 1970 Indonesia had the lowest population but it kept growing until it became third in 2000 then second in 2010 and according to the predictions it will remain the second until 2040

AI examiner evaluation

CriterionBand
Task Achievement / Task Response3.5
Coherence and Cohesion4.5
Lexical Resource5.5
Grammatical Range and Accuracy5.0
Overall4.5

Task Achievement / Task Response: Band 3.5

The response identifies a few relevant comparisons, including Malaysia’s strong rise and Indonesia’s movement from the lowest position to second place by 2010. However, it substantially misrepresents the task’s time span: the graph covers 1970–2040, but the opening says it compares predictions only from 2030 to 2040. Several statements are also inaccurate or unclear. Malaysia is not at 80% in 2040 (the figure is about 84%), and the claim that the Philippines is fourth is contradicted by the later claim that Indonesia is second; Thailand is omitted. The overview does not clearly summarise the main trends across all four countries, and the response is 25 words below the required minimum. Include the historical period, all series, and accurate key comparisons.

Coherence and Cohesion: Band 4.5

There is some basic sequencing: the response begins with a ranking, then discusses Malaysia and Indonesia, and uses links such as “followed by” and “On the other hand.” This gives the reader a rough sense of how the points relate. However, the ideas are crowded into one paragraph and the progression is difficult to follow. The opening ranking is internally confusing (“third and fourth are Philippines then Indonesia”), and the later reference to Indonesia as second does not resolve it. The response also jumps between predicted figures and historical exceptions without a clear structure. Organise the answer into an introduction, a concise overview, and grouped details, using clear comparisons to guide the reader.

Lexical Resource: Band 5.5

The response uses some relevant vocabulary for describing trends and comparisons, including “highest,” “lowest,” “kept growing,” and “noticeable difference.” These choices make the general subject understandable. However, the range is limited and several phrases are imprecise or unnatural for a graph report, such as “Comes in the first place Malaysia,” “population predictions,” and “highest population” when referring to the proportion living in cities. Spelling errors, including “thrid,” “Malasysia,” and “preceedes,” also reduce accuracy. Use precise terms such as “urban population share,” “percentage,” “ranked,” and “rose,” and check spelling carefully. More varied, accurate trend language would make comparisons clearer.

Grammatical Range and Accuracy: Band 5.0

The response attempts some longer sentence structures, including a sentence beginning “On the other hand” and a clause introduced by “where.” However, control is uneven, and the opening fragment, “Comes in the first place Malaysia,” is not a complete sentence. The first sentence also has an incorrect construction in “compares between,” while the long sentence about Malaysia combines several ideas without clear grammatical boundaries. Tense and reference are not consistently managed when historical data and predictions are discussed. Use complete, shorter sentences and check subject–verb structure and punctuation. For example, state directly that Malaysia had the highest urban share in most years, then use a separate sentence to describe the exceptions.

See this exact question answered at other band scores. The same prompt compared across bands.

Browse more IELTS Writing model answers or get your own writing scored by the same AI examiner.