Band 5.5 IELTS Writing Task 2 Model Answer

Overall Band Score: 5.5 · Cambridge IELTS 12 · 2026-11-19

IELTS Writing Task 2 question

In a number of countries, some people think it is necessary to spend large sums of money on constructing new railway lines for very fast trains between cities. Others believe the money should be spent on improving existing public transport.

Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.

Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.

 

Student answer (Band 5.5)

In a number of countries, some people think it is necessary to spend large sums of money on constructing new railway lines for very fast trains between cities. Others believe the money should be spent on improving existing public transport. We will discuss both the views further in this essay.

In this era of globalisation, several countries emphasise on constructing ultra modern high speed railways between cities to reduce the travel time. I strongly believe that this is highly beneficial in terms of efficiency and time, however, only in the countries which are already developed and do not have much national debt and the basic infrastructure is already decent. Therefore, resulting in a much sensible railway upgradation which would be beneficial for the general public.

There is another side, however, developing ultra modern high speed railways may not be the best action plan for countries with higher national debt and below par infrastructure. They should prioritise improving the existing public transport because it is going to cost significantly less than constructing an entirely new railway system. For instance, Japan, post the world war two was completely devastated and they focused on improving the conventional railway system for basic transportation. In the nineteen ninetys, they had already succeeded in maintaining their existing railway system and stabalizing the economy and therefore making room for seperate budget for high speed bullet raiway system. Now, they have the most advance railway system in the entire world, existing simultaneously with a propsering economy.

To summarise this, we can conclude that whether a country should construct a new high speed railway system or improve the existing public transport entirely depends on their current economy and infrastructure.

AI examiner evaluation

CriterionBand
Task Achievement / Task Response5.5
Coherence and Cohesion6.0
Lexical Resource5.5
Grammatical Range and Accuracy5.5
Overall5.5

Task Achievement / Task Response: Band 5.5

You discuss both options and give a conditional view: high-speed rail is worthwhile in developed countries, while countries with debt or weak infrastructure should improve existing transport first. The Japan example supports the second view, but the case for new high-speed lines is asserted mainly through “efficiency and time” and would benefit from a specific explanation or example. Your conclusion restates the dependence on a country’s circumstances rather than clearly reinforcing which option you favour overall. The response also falls short of the required minimum: it contains 240 words, and the 40 words copied from the prompt are not counted. Develop the comparison and your position with a little more relevant support to address the task more fully.

Coherence and Cohesion: Band 6.0

The essay has a clear overall arrangement: an introduction, a paragraph for each view, and a concluding summary. The contrast signalled by “There is another side, however” helps readers follow the shift to improving existing transport, and the Japan example is placed in the relevant paragraph. However, the first body paragraph’s final sentence, beginning “Therefore, resulting in…”, is a fragment and does not connect smoothly to the preceding point. The conclusion also repeats the central contrast without drawing the discussion together into a more definite final position. Use linking expressions selectively and make sure each paragraph develops a complete line of reasoning; clearer links between a country’s resources and the recommended investment would improve progression.

Lexical Resource: Band 5.5

You use some topic-specific and less common language, including “national debt,” “conventional railway system,” “infrastructure,” and “simultaneously,” which gives the response an appropriate academic focus. There are also noticeable problems with spelling and word choice that limit precision: “stabalizing,” “seperate,” “raiway,” and “propsering” should be corrected, while “highly beneficial in terms of efficiency and time” is an awkward collocation. “Ultra modern” is repeated and could be expressed more precisely. These issues do not prevent the reader from understanding your main argument, but careful proofreading and more natural collocations would make the vocabulary more controlled. Aim to choose terms that describe the specific benefit or limitation rather than relying on broad phrases such as “best action plan.”

Grammatical Range and Accuracy: Band 5.5

You attempt a mix of simple and complex forms, including the conditional idea “only in the countries which are already developed” and the contrast introduced by “however.” The main meaning is generally clear, but some sentence structures are incomplete or awkward. “Therefore, resulting in a much sensible railway upgradation” is a fragment rather than a complete sentence, and “whether a country should construct … or improve … entirely depends” places the adverb awkwardly. The long Japan sentence also joins several stages of the argument without clear grammatical control. Work on forming complete sentences and checking how clauses connect, especially after introductory phrases and linking words. More accurate sentence boundaries would make your reasoning easier to follow.

See this exact question answered at other band scores. The same prompt compared across bands.

Browse more IELTS Writing model answers or get your own writing scored by the same AI examiner.