Band 5.5 IELTS Writing Task 2 Model Answer

Overall Band Score: 5.5 · Cambridge IELTS 12 · 2026-11-22

IELTS Writing Task 2 question

In a number of countries, some people think it is necessary to spend large sums of money on constructing new railway lines for very fast trains between cities. Others believe the money should be spent on improving existing public transport.

Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.

Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.

 

Student answer (Band 5.5)

In many countries, people argue that a large amount of money should be spent to construct new railway lines between cities for fast transportation, while others think that it is wise to improve the existing public transport from that money instead of constructing a new one. This essay will address both views.

According to the first view, people believe that fast transportation is a basic necessity in today's life. It helps people to save time and perform their duties on time whether it is arriving to school or office, fast trains save time. It is difficult to renovate the existing public transportation as this requires proper planning and time. It requires a lot of time but helps to improve the economy, as more people may prefer fast trains over cars.

Other people believe that there is no need to spend a great sum of money on constructing new railway lines when there are already existing ones. It is easy to improve the old transportation than to construct a new one, as new development requires time and proper planning, and less money. The remaining money can be used for other developmental purposes. For example, if a railway line already exists, there need little need for upgrades to improve it, as the system already exists.

In my opinion, the second view is much stronger than the first. The advantages of renovation outweigh the construction of a new system.

In conclusion, the government should consult the relevant engineers to plan the renovation. This is easy approach than constructing the new lines.

AI examiner evaluation

CriterionBand
Task Achievement / Task Response5.5
Coherence and Cohesion6.0
Lexical Resource5.5
Grammatical Range and Accuracy5.5
Overall5.5

Task Achievement / Task Response: Band 5.5

You address both views and state a clear preference for improving existing transport: “the second view is much stronger.” The discussion is relevant, but the ideas are only partly developed, which limits how fully the task is answered. For the new-railway view, you mention saving time and possible economic benefits, but do not explain these benefits with a specific example or show why they justify the high cost. The case for upgrading existing services is also asserted rather than demonstrated; the example that an existing line needs “little need for upgrades” is unclear and does not support the argument convincingly. Develop each side with a concrete consequence or example, then explain more fully why your preferred option is better.

Coherence and Cohesion: Band 6.0

The response has a recognisable structure: an introduction, separate paragraphs for the two views, your opinion, and a conclusion. This makes the overall arrangement easy to follow. However, progression within paragraphs is sometimes mechanical, and some links between ideas are unclear. For example, “It requires a lot of time but helps to improve the economy” does not clearly identify what “it” refers to, while the repeated references to time and planning do not build a distinct line of reasoning. The final opinion and conclusion also repeat the preference for renovation without adding a new supporting point. Use clearer referencing and connect each claim to the next with an explanation, rather than relying mainly on repeated topic statements.

Lexical Resource: Band 5.5

You use enough topic-related vocabulary to communicate the main ideas, including “railway lines,” “public transport,” “renovate,” and “developmental purposes.” There are also attempts at more formal phrasing, such as “relevant engineers.” However, the range is limited and some word choices or combinations are inaccurate or repetitive. “Fast transportation” is repeated where more precise terms could distinguish high-speed rail from local public transport, and “new development requires time and proper planning, and less money” does not express the intended comparison clearly. “A great sum of money” is understandable but less natural in this context. Aim for precise transport and cost vocabulary, and check that each phrase expresses the intended relationship between construction, upgrading, and expenditure.

Grammatical Range and Accuracy: Band 5.5

You attempt both simple and complex sentence forms, including clauses with “as” and “whether,” and the main meaning is generally understandable. However, control is uneven, particularly in longer sentences. In “whether it is arriving to school or office, fast trains save time,” the clause is not integrated grammatically with the main statement. “There need little need for upgrades” contains an incorrect verb construction, and “This is easy approach” is missing an article. There are also punctuation and sentence-boundary problems, such as the comma splice in “It helps people to save time and perform their duties on time whether it is arriving to school or office, fast trains save time.” Build accuracy by separating complete ideas and checking articles, verb forms, and clause structure.

See this exact question answered at other band scores. The same prompt compared across bands.

Browse more IELTS Writing model answers or get your own writing scored by the same AI examiner.