Band 9.0 IELTS Writing Task 2 Model Answer

Overall Band Score: 9.0 · Cambridge IELTS 12 · 2026-08-30

IELTS Writing Task 2 question

In recent years, many small local shops have closed because customers travel to large shopping centres or malls to do their shopping.

Is this a positive or a negative development?

Give reasons for your answer and include any relevant examples from your own knowledge or experience.

 

Student answer (Band 9.0)

The migration of consumers from independent neighborhood stores to expensive shopping malls is a defining trend of modern commercial life. While this shift offers undeniable advantages in terms of convenience and variety, I believe it is a predominantly negative development because it hollows out local economies and erodes the social fabric of communities.

On the one hand, the ascendance of large shopping centers is driven by tangible benefits for the modern consumer. Malls act as one-stop hubs, where individuals can buy groceries, watch movies, and dine under a single roof. This concentration of services saves time and offers a climate-controlled, predictable environment that small shops cannot match. Furthermore, retail giants operating within these complexes benefit from economies of scale. They can leverage massive supply chains to offer lower prices and a broader selection of products, making shopping more affordable for budget-conscious families.

However, these structural advantages come at a devastating cost to local neighborhoods. The most critical drawback is the financial drain on the community. When a customer shops at a local family-owned store, a significant portion of that money is reinvested locally through wages, local taxes, and the procurement of regional goods. In contrast, multi-national chains in large malls expatriate profits to distant corporate headquarters or offshore shareholders, starving the local economy of circulating capital. Over time, this creates economic stagnation in smaller towns and suburbs.

Beyond economics, the closure of local shops inflicts severe social damage. Independent domestic businesses serve as vital community anchors where neighbors interact, fostering social cohesion and a shared sense of identity. A vibrant high street with diverse storefronts gives a town its unique character. When these shops close, they are replaced by vacant lots or generic corporate architecture, leading to the homogenization of urban spaces. Moreover, the loss of local retail disproportionately harms vulnerable populations, such as the elderly or those without vehicles, who rely on walking to nearby stores for their daily necessities.

In conclusion, while large shopping centers cater effectively to demands for efficiency and cost-effectiveness, the wider consequences are profoundly negative. The demise of small local retailers decimates neighborhood economies and dismantles the very social networks that bind communities together.

AI examiner evaluation

Task Achievement / Task Response — Band 9.0

The response fully addresses all parts of the prompt. You have taken a clear position from the introduction and maintained it consistently throughout the essay. The ideas are well-developed, with a logical balance between acknowledging the benefits of shopping malls and providing a detailed, persuasive argument regarding the negative impact on local economies and social cohesion. The use of specific concepts like 'economies of scale' and 'circulating capital' demonstrates a sophisticated engagement with the topic. The conclusion effectively synthesizes your main points without merely repeating them, ensuring the task is fully satisfied.

Coherence and Cohesion — Band 9.0

The essay is exceptionally well-organized. Each paragraph has a clear central theme, and the progression of ideas is logical and easy to follow. You use a wide range of cohesive devices, such as 'On the one hand,' 'Furthermore,' 'In contrast,' and 'Beyond economics,' which act as effective signposts for the reader. Paragraphing is used skillfully to separate the counter-argument from your primary stance. The flow between sentences is natural, and referencing is precise, ensuring that the reader never loses track of the argument's development.

Lexical Resource — Band 9.0

You demonstrate a wide and sophisticated range of vocabulary, using precise collocations and topic-specific terminology with ease. Phrases such as 'hollows out local economies,' 'erodes the social fabric,' 'expatriate profits,' and 'homogenization of urban spaces' are used accurately and naturally. The language is not only precise but also varied, showing a high level of control over register and style. There are no noticeable errors in word choice or spelling, and the vocabulary contributes significantly to the overall impact and clarity of your argument.

Grammatical Range and Accuracy — Band 9.0

The essay exhibits a wide range of complex grammatical structures, including conditional clauses, participial phrases, and varied sentence lengths. The control over punctuation and syntax is excellent, with the majority of sentences being error-free. You successfully integrate complex ideas into fluid, grammatically sound sentences, such as 'When a customer shops at a local family-owned store, a significant portion of that money is reinvested locally through wages, local taxes, and the procurement of regional goods.' There are no grammatical errors that impede communication, and the overall accuracy is very high.

See this exact question answered at other band scores — the same prompt compared across bands.

Browse more IELTS Writing model answers or get your own writing scored by the same AI examiner.